Gentleman's Agreement (1947)

Gentleman's Agreement (1947) is a journalism and media noir white Manhattan Elia Kazan civil rights and anti-Semitism writer hero idealistic restrained but powerful post World War Two racism indiscriminate prejudice thorny issues moral milestone based on Laura Z. Hobson's best-selling 1947 novel of the same title, directed by Elia Kazan about a journalist (played by Gregory Peck) who pretends to be Jewish to research an exposé on the widespread antisemitism in New York City and the affluent communities of New Canaan and Darien, Connecticut, and it was nominated for eight Academy Awards and won three: Best Picture, Best Supporting Actress (Celeste Holm), and Best Director (Elia Kazan).

Elia Kazan’s Gentleman’s Agreement [1947] is a curious object. It is courageous and cautious at the same time. It is intellectually ambitious, yet dramatically conventional. It attacks prejudice while remaining enclosed within the comfortable drawing rooms of prosperous white America. Its language can sound painfully didactic. Its romantic plot is frequently less convincing than its political one. Yet these defects do not destroy the picture. They sometimes make it more historically revealing. This is a film made by a Hollywood studio attempting to tell respectable Americans that respectability itself could provide a hiding place for intolerance. 

But yes, The Polite Architecture of Hatred! Sucha sucha good movie, deserves to be bettra known.

Its subject is therefore not principally the fanatic screaming abuse in the street. It is the civilized person who dislikes extremism but quietly accepts exclusion. That distinction remains the film’s most intelligent idea. It also explains why Gentleman’s Agreement [1947] retains greater interest than many more technically accomplished social dramas of its period. The film asks an unpleasant question. What if prejudice survives not because everyone is vicious, but because large numbers of apparently decent people find resistance inconvenient?

The narrative follows Philip Schuyler Green, played by Gregory Peck. Green is a widowed journalist who has recently arrived in New York. His publisher asks him to prepare a series of articles on anti-Jewish discrimination. At first, Green lacks an adequate method. He does not want to produce another collection of abstractions. Eventually he arrives at a theatrical solution. He will allow strangers and acquaintances to believe that he is Jewish. His name hardly needs alteration. He merely changes the social meaning attached to it. 











Once that meaning changes, so does the world around him. Hotels become inaccessible. Professional conversations acquire a different temperature. Casual remarks become suddenly audible. His son is bullied. His new romance deteriorates. The experiment gradually invades spaces that Green had imagined were private. His assignment becomes a form of social contamination. This is the dramatic mechanism on which the entire film depends. AFI records the picture as a Twentieth Century-Fox production directed by Kazan, written for the screen by Moss Hart from Laura Z. Hobson’s novel, and released in New York on 11 November 1947.

The device is artificial, of course. Green can terminate his temporary Jewish identity whenever he chooses. Dave Goldman cannot. 

Elaine Wales cannot. That difference is one of the film’s most conspicuous limitations. Green may enter prejudice as though entering a laboratory, but he retains the privilege of leaving the experiment. The film knows this to some extent because Dave repeatedly supplies a reality deeper than Green’s recently acquired indignation. Yet the dramatic emphasis remains attached to the Gentile convert. This creates a moral paradox. Hollywood wished to expose anti-Semitism but believed the safest vehicle was a conspicuously non-Jewish star discovering it. Contemporary criticism noticed the problem. 








TCM notes that Ring Lardner joked that the film seemed to warn audiences against mistreating a Jewish man because he might secretly be Gentile. Bosley Crowther likewise objected that Green encountered prejudice mainly within affluent social and professional circles. Those criticisms are justified. They are not fatal. The film’s very limitations disclose the boundaries within which a major American studio believed such a subject could be discussed.

Kathy Lacey: You think I'm an anti-Semite.

Phil Green: No, I don't. But I've come to see lots of nice people who hate it and deplore it and protest their own innocence, then help it along and wonder why it grows. People who would never beat up a Jew. People who think anti-Semitism is far away in some dark place with low-class morons. That's the biggest discovery I've made. The good people. The nice people.

Its great perception concerns the social grammar of discrimination. Hatred need not announce itself with violence. It can operate through a reservation mysteriously unavailable. It can appear in a personnel office. It can be embedded in property customs. It can survive inside a joke. It can live in the pause before an invitation is offered. 

The title refers to this unwritten machinery. No statute is required. No signed document is necessary. A social group understands what sort of person is welcome and what sort is not. The agreement is effective precisely because nobody has to articulate it. The system acquires the appearance of nature. Exclusion therefore becomes difficult to prosecute because each individual act appears trivial. A hotel refusal is merely a hotel refusal. A rejected application is merely an administrative decision. A dinner-table remark is merely a remark. Kazan and Hart accumulate these incidents until triviality itself becomes sinister. The film’s moral force comes from aggregation. Small acts create a large structure.



That structure also explains Kathy Lacy, played by Dorothy McGuire. She is not written as a conventional monster. Such a characterization would make the drama easier and less interesting. Kathy believes herself enlightened. She disapproves of crude bigotry. She dislikes anti-Semitic language. She recognizes prejudice as something ugly. Her failure is more embarrassing. She does not wish opposition to intolerance to disturb the architecture of her own life. She would rather regret injustice than create a scene. She would prefer moral correctness without social discomfort. Green eventually finds this inadequate. Their romance then becomes a political argument disguised as melodrama. This is dramatically repetitive.

It also produces some of the film’s stiffest passages. Peck can become prosecutorial, while McGuire is required to defend hesitation for scene after scene. Nevertheless, Kathy embodies one of the screenplay’s most durable propositions. Passive liberalism can become an accomplice to the very customs it claims to dislike.

The romantic material remains the weakest substantial element. Green and Kathy repeatedly seem less like lovers than participants in a seminar on civic responsibility. Their courtship possesses little sensuality. Their reconciliation can feel narratively compulsory. Anne Dettrey, played by Celeste Holm, seems considerably more attractive as a companion for Green. She is witty. She is socially agile. She can laugh without appearing frivolous. 






Most importantly, her ethical convictions have already become behaviour. She does not require Green to explain courage to her. The frustrating quality of the romantic resolution therefore has an unusual effect. The spectator may understand why Green forgives Kathy while still preferring Anne. The picture chooses moral rehabilitation over romantic chemistry. Kathy must be educable because the film is addressed largely to people like Kathy. Her conversion is part of the argument. Anne, already persuaded, has nowhere ideological to travel.

Holm’s performance helps expose this structural difficulty. Her Anne possesses velocity. She enters scenes with an intelligence that appears to precede the screenplay. Holm does not merely deliver correct opinions. She gives the impression that Anne has lived before the camera arrived. Her humour also rescues the picture from its pervasive solemnity. The Academy rewarded Holm with the Oscar for supporting actress, one of three awards won by the film. The others were Best Picture and Best Director for Kazan.

 The picture received eight nominations in total. Holm subsequently appeared as Susie Smith in the noir-inflected Road House [1948], alongside Ida Lupino, Cornel Wilde and Richard Widmark. That film surrounds its characters with jealousy, claustrophobia and fatalistic atmosphere. She later appeared in The Snake Pit [1948] and gave another celebrated supporting performance in All About Eve [1950]. Her work in Gentleman’s Agreement [1947] is valuable partly because Anne refuses to become a solemn emblem of goodness.

Gregory Peck occupies the film with a very different energy. His Philip Green is severe. He carries rectitude as though it were physical weight. That quality would later become central to his image as Atticus Finch in To Kill a Mockingbird [1962]. Yet Green is less serene than Atticus. He becomes angry, impatient and occasionally bullying. This can make him difficult company. It also prevents the part from dissolving entirely into sanctity. 

Peck had already worked inside noir territory in Alfred Hitchcock’s Spellbound [1945], where he played an amnesiac whose unstable identity is connected to the possibility of murder. TCM explicitly categorizes that picture as noir as well as drama. Peck also showed a darker register in Duel in the Sun [1946], and later brought remarkable austerity to The Gunfighter [1950]. His upright physical presence made him particularly useful to Gentleman’s Agreement [1947]. The film needs prejudice to be revealed as irrational even when directed at a man who looks like Hollywood’s own image of unquestionable social legitimacy.

Dorothy McGuire faces a less grateful assignment. Kathy must be sympathetic enough to retain Green’s love while compromised enough to embody complacency. The role can therefore appear colourless beside Anne. McGuire’s restraint should not simply be mistaken for absence. She had already demonstrated a remarkable capacity for expressing fear and vulnerability in Robert Siodmak’s The Spiral Staircase [1946]. There she played a mute woman threatened by a murderer inside a Gothic house. The performance required much of its emotional meaning to be carried without dialogue. 

TCM describes that picture as a model Gothic thriller, photographed by Nicholas Musuraca, one of the cinematographers most closely associated with noir atmosphere. McGuire had also appeared opposite Robert Mitchum and Guy Madison in Edward Dmytryk’s Till the End of Time [1946], a drama about veterans struggling with the psychological and physical consequences of the Second World War. Her quietness in Gentleman’s Agreement [1947] is thus deliberate. The difficulty lies less in her competence than in a screenplay that makes hesitation her principal dramatic activity.

John Garfield brings an altogether different authority to Dave Goldman. His presence changes the moral texture of the film. Green is conducting an investigation. Dave has accumulated experience. He does not need a social experiment to discover what prejudice feels like. 

Garfield therefore makes even relatively brief scenes feel heavier than Green’s elaborate research project. The casting acquires additional force because Garfield was Jewish and accepted the supporting role despite already possessing leading-man status. TCM records that he believed strongly in the film’s subject. His career also places Gentleman’s Agreement [1947] directly beside the noir tradition. In The Postman Always Rings Twice [1946], Garfield played Frank Chambers, the drifting lover pulled into adultery and murder. TCM describes the film as one of the key works in noir’s development. I

n Body and Soul [1947], he played a boxer consumed by corruption, and the film used hard lighting and social pessimism that helped shape later boxing dramas. He then played the compromised lawyer Joe Morse in Abraham Polonsky’s Force of Evil [1948], an explicit noir about criminal capitalism. His final film, He Ran All the Way [1951], intensified noir fatalism through a doomed fugitive, urban confinement and pervasive paranoia. Few actors connect Kazan’s social drama so directly to noir’s wounded postwar masculinity.

The supporting characters widen the picture beyond Green’s individual experience. His young son Tommy shows how inherited prejudice reaches children before they possess the intellectual vocabulary to understand it. His suffering is particularly effective because the experiment was not his decision. Green chooses the masquerade. Tommy inherits its consequences. Mrs. Green, played by Anne Revere, supplies the film with an older progressive conscience. Her speeches occasionally approach the tone of a civic pamphlet, yet her optimism is historically revealing. She imagines the exposure of injustice as evidence that America might still improve. 

Elaine Wales offers a more disturbing case. She has concealed her Jewish identity behind a less conspicuous name in order to obtain employment. She has absorbed some of the hierarchy that injured her. The film handles this material imperfectly, especially when Green assumes the authority to lecture her. Yet Elaine illustrates an important psychological mechanism. A discriminatory order does not merely exclude. It pressures the excluded person to negotiate with the values of the excluding group.

A gendered reading complicates the film further. Men receive most of the picture’s ideological authority. Green investigates. Dave authenticates. Minify commissions. Women are more often required to demonstrate competing responses to male moral action. Kathy hesitates. Anne approves. Elaine internalizes damage. Mrs. Green supplies wisdom. This organization limits the women even while giving several of them unusually intelligent dialogue. 


Kathy is particularly revealing. Her central problem is not private hatred but social conditioning. She has been trained to preserve civility. She understands that a woman within her social class should smooth conflict rather than create it. Her initial failure to challenge an anti-Semitic joke is therefore connected to gender as well as class. The demand that she become morally active requires her to violate the behaviour expected of the gracious affluent woman. Anne has already done so. 

Her humour permits her to enter public conversation without surrendering independence. She is professionally employed, verbally confident and socially mobile. It is hardly surprising that she feels more modern than Kathy. Yet the screenplay finally rewards Kathy with romantic restoration. Anne’s greater autonomy is admired, then narratively set aside. The ending consequently returns a politically disruptive film to a rather conventional heterosexual arrangement.

The year 1947 gives this argument exceptional historical pressure. The Second World War had ended only two years earlier. Knowledge of the extermination of European Jewry was now impossible to dismiss, yet the defeat of Nazi Germany had not abolished American anti-Semitism. The distinction matters. The United States had fought a totalitarian enemy whose racial ideology culminated in industrialized mass murder. 

That did not mean every American institution had suddenly rejected its own discriminatory customs. Indeed, President Harry Truman made precisely this connection on 29 October 1947, less than two weeks before the New York opening of Gentleman’s Agreement [1947]. In releasing the report of his Committee on Civil Rights, Truman warned that racial and religious intolerance had reappeared after the war and threatened the principles for which the nation claimed to have fought. The film therefore belongs to an immediate national argument rather than a distant retrospective judgment.

Other events made 1947 equally unstable. On 12 March, Truman announced the policy that became known as the Truman Doctrine. It committed the United States to assisting governments threatened by authoritarian pressure and marked a decisive expansion of American Cold War involvement. At home, however, political conformity was becoming increasingly coercive. 

In October, only weeks before the film opened, the House Un-American Activities Committee conducted nine days of hearings into alleged Communist influence in Hollywood. The proceedings helped produce the Hollywood blacklist and the persecution of the Hollywood Ten. 

The contradiction is striking. America proclaimed itself the global guardian of political liberty while subjecting artists to ideological investigation. On 29 November, eighteen days after the film’s New York opening, the United Nations adopted Resolution 181 recommending the partition of Palestine into Arab and Jewish states. Questions of Jewish identity, refuge, nationalism and belonging were therefore matters of immediate international consequence. Gentleman’s Agreement [1947] arrived inside this atmosphere of moral declaration and political anxiety.

Its place in the larger history of the United States lies precisely in this contradiction between national ideals and social practice. American political culture has repeatedly defined the republic through universal language while distributing the benefits of citizenship unevenly. The Declaration of Independence offered equality as a principle. 

American institutions repeatedly qualified that promise according to race, sex, religion, property and ancestry. In 1947 this contradiction was becoming difficult to hide. Black veterans had returned from fighting fascism to a nation still governed in many regions by Jim Crow. 

Restrictive housing practices limited where minority families could live. Religious prejudice remained socially respectable in circles that would have rejected the label of extremism. Truman’s civil-rights committee called its report To Secure These Rights and explicitly measured American practice against the nation’s professed democratic inheritance. Gentleman’s Agreement [1947] performs a similar operation in popular culture. It asks the prosperous middle and upper classes to examine the distance between what America says about itself and what Americans quietly permit.

This national self-examination also explains why the film should be considered in relation to film noir. It is not a conventional crime noir. There is no murder investigation. Green is not pursued through rain-soaked alleys. Kathy is not a femme fatale. Arthur Miller’s cinematography is generally polished rather than expressionistically nightmarish. 

Yet noir is larger than a catalogue of Venetian blinds and revolvers. The noir tradition of the 1940s repeatedly investigated the instability beneath postwar American confidence. Its protagonists encounter systems they initially believe they understand. Gradually, familiar institutions become strange. Identity becomes uncertain. Respectable surfaces conceal predatory structures. 

Gentleman’s Agreement [1947] uses those ideas in social rather than criminal form. Green changes one fact about how society perceives him and discovers an alternative America occupying the same streets, offices and hotels.


The comparison with Edward Dmytryk’s Crossfire [1947] is especially revealing. Both films attacked anti-Semitism in the same year. TCM notes that Crossfire [1947] reached audiences first and used the form of film noir to investigate the murder of a Jewish man. Its hatred becomes physical. Violence supplies the crime around which the story develops. Gentleman’s Agreement [1947] examines something less spectacular. 

Its villains are dispersed. There is no single murderer who can be arrested and removed. The enemy is a network of habits. That makes Kazan’s film less visually noir but, in another sense, deeply compatible with noir pessimism. A noir hero often discovers that corruption is systemic. Green makes a similar discovery. He cannot defeat prejudice by exposing one criminal because prejudice has no single body. It resides in language, custom, property, employment and friendship. The darkness is social rather than photographic.

Kazan’s direction appropriately avoids excessive visual flamboyance. He would later become associated with the intense performances and physical environments of A Streetcar Named Desire [1951] and On the Waterfront [1954]. Here his manner is restrained. Rooms are allowed to feel ordinary. This is important. If every prejudiced character inhabited a grotesque expressionist world, the spectator could place evil safely at a distance. 

Instead, intolerance appears beneath tasteful furniture and civilized conversation. Alfred Newman’s music is also used with relative restraint. The film is dominated by speech. At times this becomes burdensome. Yet the comparative absence of melodramatic punctuation can also make encounters feel unpleasantly plausible. The characters frequently injure one another while maintaining proper social posture. The mise-en-scène becomes an architecture of etiquette.

The film’s production history gives its argument further weight. Laura Z. Hobson’s novel had already become a bestseller. AFI records that Darryl F. Zanuck regarded the project as sufficiently risky that he feared failure might discourage Hollywood from treating prejudice openly for years. It also records Kazan’s recollection that several Jewish studio executives urged against making the picture because they feared provoking additional anti-Semitism. 

The hesitation is understandable. Hollywood itself existed in an awkward position. Many powerful figures in the industry were Jewish, yet the studios had long been reluctant to address Jewish identity explicitly. The film therefore represents not simple bravery but institutional anxiety transformed into prestige production. Zanuck’s decision was rewarded commercially and critically. That success demonstrated that an American mass audience could be asked to confront anti-Semitism directly, even if the confrontation remained carefully packaged.

There is an additional historical irony. The film condemns the cowardice of remaining silent when other people are targeted. Yet Hollywood was moving rapidly into a political climate in which silence, accusation and denunciation would determine careers. HUAC’s investigations eventually touched several people associated with the production. John Garfield was blacklisted after refusing to identify others as Communists. 

Anne Revere’s career was also damaged by the blacklist. Kazan later cooperated with HUAC and named former Communist associates, a decision that permanently complicated his reputation. TCM notes these later consequences while also recording Peck’s opposition to HUAC’s actions. It would be simplistic to force the film into a prophecy of the blacklist. Nevertheless, its preoccupation with the moral responsibilities of witnesses acquired an importance its makers could scarcely have controlled. The question “What do you do when someone else is being excluded?” soon became brutally personal within Hollywood itself.

The film can unquestionably be preachy. Some conversations seem written not for characters but for an audience expected to take notes. Green occasionally behaves as though eight weeks of borrowed stigma have made him the supreme authority on another group’s history. The relationship with Kathy receives more time than its emotional credibility warrants. Mrs. Green sometimes speaks in polished proclamations rather than ordinary conversation. 

The ending is tidier than the subject deserves. Yet it would be peculiar to dismiss the entire film because it argues too visibly. Social-problem pictures are inevitably burdened by exposition. More importantly, the picture’s moral pressure emerges from an issue that polite American culture had preferred not to discuss. Its earnestness is partly the earnestness of a door being forced open.

Nor should the film’s concentration on affluent white society be treated only as cowardice. It certainly narrows the range of experience shown. It does not approach the extremities of American racial violence. It gives little attention to poverty or the intersection between anti-Semitism and other forms of discrimination. Yet its chosen environment has analytical value. Gentleman’s Agreement [1947] is interested in people who regard themselves as incapable of prejudice. The country club matters because its members possess education. 

The magazine office matters because its employees consider themselves sophisticated. Kathy matters because she believes in tolerance. The film deliberately removes ignorance as an easy explanation. Its characters often know the correct principle. Their failure lies in refusing to pay the social price demanded by that principle.

This is why the picture continues to possess educational power despite its age. It does not merely tell the spectator that fanaticism is evil. Very few viewers need a two-hour film to discover that proposition. Instead, it examines the smaller accommodations through which intolerance remains comfortable. The joke that receives no objection matters. 


The restricted hotel matters. The job applicant who changes a surname matters. The friend who expresses sympathy but avoids confrontation matters. These incidents do not carry the spectacular horror of genocide. The film never suggests that they do. Its argument is that democratic culture deteriorates when ordinary citizens train themselves to overlook ordinary exclusions.

The achievement of Gentleman’s Agreement [1947] therefore rests less in cinematic perfection than in moral disturbance. It is not Kazan’s greatest film. It is not Peck’s greatest performance. Its lovers are not especially convincing. Its speeches occasionally stiffen into instruction. Nevertheless, its imperfections belong to a work attempting something unusual within the industrial Hollywood of 1947. 

It exposes an American habit of separating public ideals from private conduct. It shows prejudice operating without uniforms, rallies or official decrees. It recognizes that hatred can wear excellent clothes. It also recognizes that opposition to hatred requires more than private disapproval.

For that reason, the final significance of the film lies with the apparently minor decision to object. Dave already knows this. Anne already practices it. Kathy must learn it. Green, for all his self-righteousness, becomes obsessed with it. 

The moral world of the picture divides less cleanly between bigots and non-bigots than between people willing to interrupt discrimination and people prepared to remain comfortable beside it. That idea connects the film to the anxieties of its year, to the contradictions of American democracy, and to the fatalistic social vision associated with noir. Gentleman’s Agreement [1947] may sometimes speak too loudly. Its most unsettling subject, however, is silence.

Mrs. Green: You know something, Phil? I suddenly want to live to be very old. Very. I want to be around to see what happens. The world is stirring in very strange ways. Maybe this is the century for it. Maybe that's why it's so troubled. Other centuries had their driving forces. What will ours have been when men look back? Maybe it won't be the American century after all... or the Russian century or the atomic century. Wouldn't it be wonderful... if it turned out to be everybody's century... when people all over the world - free people - found a way to live together? I'd like to be around to see some of that... even the beginning. I may stick around for quite a while.



Tommy Green: What's anti-Semitism?

Phil Green: Well, uh, that's when some people don't like other people just because they're Jews.

Tommy Green: Why not? Are Jews bad?

Phil Green: Well, some are and some aren't, just like with everyone else.

Tommy Green: What are Jews, anyway?

Phil Green: Well, uh, it's like this. Remember last week when you asked me about that big church, and I told you there are all different kinds of churches? Well, the people who go to that particular church are called Catholics, and there are people who go to different churches and they're called Protestants, and there are people who go to different churches and they're called Jews, only they call their churches temples or synagogues.

Tommy Green: Why don't some people like them?

Phil Green: Well, I can't really explain it, Tommy.



Anne Dettrey: I know dear, and some of your other best friends are Methodist, but you never bother to say it.

 


Tommy Green: They were playing hop, and I asked if I could play too, and the one from school said no dirty little Jew could play with them. And they all yelled those other things. I started to speak, and they all yelled that my father has a long curly beard, and they turned and ran. Why did they, Pop? Why?

Phil Green: Come on , drink some of this.

[offering a glass of water]

Phil Green: Did you want to tell them that you weren't really Jewish?

Tommy Green: No.

Phil Green: That's good. See, there's are a lot of kids just like you Tommy, who are Jewish, and if you said it, it would sort of be admitting there was something bad in being Jewish; and something swell in not.

Tommy Green: They wouldn't fight. They just ran.

Phil Green: Yeah, I know. There's a lot of grown-ups just like that too, Tom, only they do it with wisecracks instead of with yelling.



Professor Fred Lieberman: Millions of people nowadays are religious only in the vaguest sense. I've often wondered why the Jews among them still go on calling themselves Jews. Do you know, Mr. Green?

Phil Green: No, but I'd like to.

Professor Fred Lieberman: Because the world still makes it an advantage not to be one. Thus it becomes a matter of pride to go on calling ourselves Jews.



Elaine Wales: I changed my name. Did you?

Phil Green: Green has always been my name. What's yours?

 

 

Elaine Wales: Estelle Walovsky. I couldn't take it. The applications, I mean. So one day I wrote the same firm two letters, same as you're doing now. I sent the Elaine Wales one, and I sent it after they said there were no openings. Well, I got the job, all right. Do you know what firm that was? "Smith's Weekly."

Phil Green: No.

Elaine Wales: Yes, Mr. Green. The great liberal magazine that fights injustice on all sides.



Mrs. Green: Are you very disappointed, Phil?

Phil Green: Yes, I am. I was almost sure he'd hand me the Stassen story or Washington. Oh, I wasn't looking for an easy one, Ma, but I did want something I could make good on. I'd so like the first one here to be a natural. Something I know they would read.

Mrs. Green: Oh, you mean, there's enough anti-Semitism in real life without people reading about it?

Phil Green: No, but this one's doomed before I start. What can I say that hasn't been said before?

Mrs. Green: I don't know. Maybe it hasn't been said well enough. If it had, you wouldn't have had to explain it to Tommy just now, or you father and I to you. It would be nice sometime, not to have to explain it to someone like Tommy. Kids are so decent to start with.



Phil Green: I've been saying I'm Jewish, and it works.

Dave Goldman: Why, you crazy fool! It's working?

Phil Green: It works too well. I've been having my nose rubbed in it, and I don't like the smell.

Dave Goldman: You're not insulated yet, Phil. The impact must be quite a business on you.

Phil Green: You mean you get indifferent to it in time?

Dave Goldman: No, but you're concentrating a lifetime into a few weeks. You're not changing the facts, you're just making them hurt more.

 



Tommy Green: Pop, what's that?

Phil Green: That's a statue of Atlas carrying the world on his shoulders.

Tommy Green: No kidding? That's what Grandma says you're doing. She says she wishes you'd leave the world alone once in a while.



Elaine Wales: You just let them get one wrong Jew in here, and it'll come out of us. It's no fun being the fall guy for the kikey ones.

Phil Green: Miss Wales, I'm going to be frank with you. I want you to know that words like yid and kike and kikey and coon and nigger make me sick no matter who says them.

Elaine Wales: Oh, but I only said it for a type.

Phil Green: Yeah, but we're talking about a the word first.

Elaine Wales: Why, sometimes I even say it to myself, about me, I mean. Like, if I'm about to do something I know I shouldn't, I'll say, "Don't be such a little kike." That's all.



Phil Green: What makes you say that?

Bert McAnny: Oh, I don't know. You just seem like... a clever sort of guy.

Phil Green: What makes you think I wasn't a G.I.?

Bert McAnny: What? Now, Green, don't get me wrong. Why, some of my best friends are Jews.

Anne Dettrey: And some of your other best friends are Methodists, but you never bother to say that.

Phil Green: I'm going up to Flume Inn. I'm gonna use those plane tickets we had for this afternoon. I'll be back later.

Kathy Lacey: Phil, what for?

Dave Goldman: You're wasting your time.

Phil Green: Sure, but there must be a time once when you fight back, Dave. I want to make them look me in the eye and do it. I-I want the satisfaction. I can't explain it, but I want to do it for myself.

Kathy Lacey: Phil, they're nothing more than...

Dave Goldman: Let him do it, Kathy. You have to face them once. I did it once at Monterey.

Phil Green: They are more than nasty little snobs, Kathy. You call them that, and you can dismiss them; it's too easy. They're persistent little traitors to everything that this country stands for, and stands on and you have to fight 'em! Not just for the 'poor, poor Jews,' as Dave says, but for everything this country stands for.



Dave Goldman: There was a boy in our outfit... Abe Schlussman. Good soldier. Good engineer. One night, we got bombed, and he caught it. I was ten yards off. Somebody said... ''Give me a hand with this sheeny.'' Those were the last words he ever heard.



Anne Dettrey: They scold Bilbo and think they've fought the good fight for democracy in this country. They haven't got the guts to go from talking to action. One little action on one little front. Sure, I know its not the whole answer, but its got to start somewhere, and it's got to start with passion. Not pamphlets, not even your series. It's got to be with people. Rich people, poor people, big and little people. And it's got to be quick.



John Minify: I've asked Phil to do a piece on anti-Semitism.

Kathy Lacey: Am I going to get a credit line?

John Minify: You? Why?

Kathy Lacey: Well, don't you remember last winter when that Jewish schoolteacher resigned, and I...

John Minify: Oh, yes. Well, I knew somebody would be asking me for a credit line. I'm always stealing ideas without realizing it.

Kathy Lacey: That's what makes your magazine so original.



Kathy Lacey: Oh, Dave, we couldn't get married without you. What happened?

Dave Goldman: Nothing. That's just it. I can't abandon my family forever, and I can't find a house or an apartment. If it was just me, I'd sleep on the subway, but I've got Carol and the kids. I've got to go back. I'm licked.

Phil Green: But that means your job, your whole future.

Dave Goldman: I'll live. I've done it before.

Kathy Lacey: But, Dave, that's terrible.



Tommy Green: They called me a dirty Jew and a stinking kike, and they all ran away.

Kathy Lacey: Oh, darling, it's not true. You're no more Jewish than I am. It's just some horrible mistake.

Phil Green: Kathy!



Phil Green: You aren't going to fit it at all, Kathy! You're just going to give in and let their idiotic rules stand!

Kathy Lacey: What can one person do?

Phil Green: What can they do?

Kathy Lacey: Plenty! Ostracize him!

Phil Green: And you expect me to live there now that I know all this?

Kathy Lacey: Oh, you can't change the whole world!


Kathy Lacey: I love this house, deeply... and I started to build it when things first began to go wrong between Bill and me. And somehow it became a symbol to me of many things. Sometimes, when you're troubled and hurt, you pour yourself into things that can't hurt back.



Phil Green: You want the moon!

John Minify: yeah!... with parsley.



Phil Green: Ma, I've got it! I've got the idea, the angle, the lead. I'll be Jewish! Why, all I've got to do is just say it! No one around here knows me. I can live with myself for six weeks, eight weeks, nine months. Ma, this is it!

Mrs. Green: It must be. It always is when you're this sure.

Phil Green: Ma, listen, I've even got the title. "I Was Jewish for Six Months."

Mrs. Green: It's right, Phil.

Phil Green: Ma, it's like this click just happened inside me. It won't be the same, sure, but it'll be close. I can just tell them I'm Jewish and see what happens.

 

 

Mrs. Green: It'll work fine, Phil.

Phil Green: Dark hair, dark eyes. Just like Dave. Just like a lot of guys who aren't Jewish. No accent, no mannerisms. Neither has Dave.



Phil Green: No, no, I'm fine. I just wish I was dead is all.



Phil Green: You still think of your mom, Tommy?

Tommy Green: Sometimes. Not all the time. Just sometimes. How old was I when she died, Pop?

Phil Green: You were four years old. It's been a long time.

Tommy Green: You ever gonna get married again?

Phil Green: Maybe. You want me to?

Tommy Green: I don't care. I like it fine this way.



Phil Green: I'm doing a series for him on anti-Semitism.

Professor Fred Lieberman: For or against?

Phil Green: Well, he thought we might hash over some ideas.

Professor Fred Lieberman: What sort of ideas?

 

 

Phil Green: Palestine, for instance. Zionism.

Professor Fred Lieberman: Which? Palestine as a refuge... or Zionism as a movement for a Jewish state?

Phil Green: The confusion between the two, more than anything.

Professor Fred Lieberman: If we agree there's confusion, we can talk. We scientists love confusion...



Phil Green: Some people hate Catholics, some people hate Jews.

Tommy Green: And no one hates us because we're Americans.



Phil Green: Funny thing, that girl, Mr. Minify's niece suggested the series on antisemitism. Funny.

Mrs. Green: You don't say? Why, women will be thinking next, Phil.



Anne Dettrey: Mirror, mirror, on the wall, who's the most brilliant of them all?

Phil Green: And what does the mirror say?

Anne Dettrey: Well, that mirror ain't no gentleman.


Mrs. Green: I never realized pain could be so... sharp.



Kathy Lacey: I was right not to settle. I was right to keep dreaming, because it's all come true. Darling, we're going to be so happy here. This house and I were waiting for you. I was always waiting for you, I think.



Kathy Lacey: I called up my sister Jane and blurted it out, and she squealed, "Kathy!" as if she had given up any hope of anyone ever asking me. She's aching to meet you. She and her husband are giving a big party for us on Sunday. By the way, won't we have to let Jane in on it?

Phil Green: I hadn't thought so.

Kathy Lacey: But we will, won't we? Your mother knows.

Phil Green: She had to. Jane and her husband don't. If you want to keep a secret...

Kathy Lacey: But wouldn't it be sort of exaggerated with my own sister? Your sister-in-law, almost. I do think it would be inflexible of you.

Phil Green: I suppose it would be, inside the family. But they won't let anybody know, will they?

Kathy Lacey: They won't breathe it. They want to fight this awful thing just as much as you and I do.



Phil Green: So far I've been digging in facts and data-I've sort of been ignoring feelings.



Phil Green: I'm going to let everybody know I'm Jewish.

Kathy Lacey: Jewish? But you're not! Are you? Not that it would make any difference to me. But you said, "Let everybody know," as if you hadn't before and would now. So I just wondered. Not that it would make any difference to me. Phil, you're annoyed.

Phil Green: No, I'm just thinking.

Kathy Lacey: Well, don't look serious about it. Surely you must know where I stand.

Phil Green: Oh, I do.

Kathy Lacey: You just caught me off-guard.



Tommy Green: Pop, are we Jewish? Jimmy Kelley said we were. Our janitor told his janitor. 

Phil Green: Well, what did you tell Jimmy Kelley?

Tommy Green: I said I'd ask you.

Phil Green: Well, it's like this. Remember that movie Kathy and I took you to, and you asked if things like that really happened?

Tommy Green: Kathy said they were pretending.

Phil Green: Well, I'm pretending I'm Jewish for something I'm writing.

Tommy Green: You mean like a game?

Phil Green: Yes, but I'd appreciate it if you promised not to tell anybody it's a game.

Tommy Green: Okay, Pop, sure.


Resort Clerk: In answer to your question, do you follow the Hebrew religion yourself, or do you just want to make sure?

Phil Green: I've asked a simple question, and I'd like a simple answer.

Resort Clerk: Well, we have a very high-class clientele, and, well...

Phil Green: Then you do restrict your guests to Gentiles?

Resort Clerk: Well, I would hardly say that, and in any event, there seems to have been some mistake because we don't have a single free room in the entire hotel.


Kathy Lacey: You can't help that you were born Christian instead of Jewish. It doesn't mean you're glad you were. But I am glad. There, I said it.


Tommy Green: Grandma said to wake you.

Phil Green: It's late, isn't it?

Tommy Green: Yeah. Here's your bathrobe.

Phil Green: I don't want it.

         Tommy Green: Put it on, I said!


 

Phil Green: I don't have to kiss you in public, I have a nice, dark taxi outside

[to Kathy]

Phil Green: .


Kathy Lacey: You can't make over the whole world. You know I'm on Dave's side.

Phil Green: Well, I'm not on Dave's side or any side, except against their side.


Tommy Green: Don't you ever think of what to write yourself?


John Minify: I wouldn't call a dog Schuyler.


Elia Kazan occupies an especially revealing position within the ideological machinery of twentieth-century American cinema. His work is saturated with class conflict, alienation, institutional violence and the psychic injuries produced by hierarchy; yet his historical conduct during the anti-communist purges of the 1950s aligned him, finally and materially, with the very apparatuses of bourgeois power his films so frequently appeared to expose. The contradiction is not incidental. It is the key to Kazan, says I, at least I, not the big machine, but I.

The conventional liberal account treats this contradiction as a tragic conflict between “the artist” and “the man”. A Marxist criticism should reject such mystification. There is no politically innocent artist floating above material history. Kazan worked inside institutions: Broadway, Hollywood, the studio system, congressional anti-communism, the Academy. His films were commodities produced by organised labour and capital, and his celebrated psychological realism emerged from a specific historical moment in which American culture increasingly translated collective social antagonisms into private dramas of individual conscience.

Kazan’s creative formation nevertheless belongs unmistakably to the cultural Left. His closest collaborators included Arthur Miller, Tennessee Williams, John Steinbeck and Budd Schulberg, writers repeatedly concerned with class domination, exclusion, labour, repression and the violence concealed beneath American respectability. His relationship with writers was unusually close, and Williams considered Kazan capable of enlarging his work through direction.

This collaborative practice itself complicates the bourgeois mythology of the auteur. Cinema presents itself commercially through the proper name of the director, but Kazan’s films arose from collective labour: writers, performers, designers, technicians and crews. The auteur becomes, in ideological terms, a useful fetish. The labour of many is condensed into the prestige of one.

Yet Kazan would increasingly embrace precisely this conception of singular authority. In later life he repudiated the idea of theatre as a collective art and argued that successful work should express the vision and conviction of one dominant individual. The movement is revealing: from collectivist cultural formation towards the sovereign bourgeois creator.

His directing method offers the same contradiction at the level of performance. Kazan wanted actors who appeared socially and psychologically real. His preference for comparatively unknown performers helped produce some of the decisive screen presences of postwar American cinema, including James Dean, Eva Marie Saint, Lee Remick, Warren Beatty and Andy Griffith. He sought bodies not yet completely disciplined by the industrial mannerisms of stardom.

The Method, in this context, becomes something more than an acting technique. It is a technology for rendering contradiction visible upon the body.

Kazan’s characters hesitate, sweat, mumble, explode. Their social injuries appear as neurosis. Class domination becomes shame; patriarchal authority becomes paternal terror; economic dependence becomes erotic desperation. The system inscribes itself upon muscle and gesture.

This was a great aesthetic achievement, but also a potentially conservative displacement. Capitalism disappears as an economic structure and returns as personal anguish.

The worker does not confront capital.

The son confronts the father.

The woman confronts the lover.

The outsider confronts himself.

Historical antagonism is psychologised.

This is one of the characteristic operations of American liberal cinema: social contradiction is acknowledged intensely enough to generate drama but displaced into individual morality before it can become collective politics.

Kazan’s extraordinary skill with actors intensified this process. He regarded performance as the excavation of something already present in the actor and would manipulate real emotional material to produce cinematic authenticity. Marlon Brando, while revering Kazan’s abilities, called him an “arch-manipulator” of actors’ emotions.

There is almost a miniature labour relation here.

The actor supplies emotional labour.

The director extracts it.

The studio packages it.

The spectator purchases its appearance as authenticity.

Under Hollywood capitalism, alienation itself can be made profitable.

Kazan’s genius was to understand the emotional costs of American society while remaining extraordinarily successful within the industry that commodified those costs.

A Face in the Crowd is perhaps his clearest account of ideology as commodity. Its demagogue does not initially require coherent political doctrine. He requires circulation, intimacy, charisma and technological amplification. Television manufactures political authority in the same manner that advertising manufactures desire.

Kazan and Schulberg explicitly understood television as a potential political force and warned audiences not to confuse personality with political substance.

From a Marxist standpoint, however, the film goes further than its makers perhaps consciously intended. It demonstrates that under advanced capitalism political consciousness itself becomes susceptible to commodity logic. The politician is marketed. Authenticity is branded. Reaction is packaged as spontaneity.

The citizen is interpellated primarily as consumer.

Democracy approaches advertising.

Politics becomes spectacle.

This remains one of Kazan’s most prophetic insights.

Yet the fundamental political rupture in his career comes in 1952.

Kazan had belonged to the Communist Party USA during the Depression. When called before the House Un-American Activities Committee during the Red Scare, he initially resisted naming former comrades but subsequently identified eight people associated with the Group Theatre as Communists.

A liberal interpretation tends to construct this as an agonising moral dilemma: conscience against loyalty, anti-Stalinism against friendship, personal freedom against Party discipline.

A Marxist account begins elsewhere.

What institution possessed coercive power?

Not the Communist Party Kazan had left sixteen years earlier.

The American state did.

HUAC operated inside a broader political economy of repression in which employers, studios, newspapers and government collaborated to render left-wing political affiliation economically punishable. The blacklist did not merely regulate opinion; it controlled access to labour.

To be named was potentially to be separated from one's means of livelihood.

The blacklist was therefore class discipline.

It informed cultural workers that their labour could be withdrawn from the market if their politics challenged the boundaries established by American capital.

Kazan’s testimony must be understood inside that material structure. He preserved his own capacity to sell his labour at the expense of people whose ability to sell theirs was endangered.

The ideological language of “conscience” should not obscure the economic transaction.

Kazan chose continued access to the cultural means of production.

Others lost theirs.

His subsequent public defence of that decision made the rupture deeper. He did not merely comply privately but took out newspaper advertising to justify his actions and encourage others to follow his example.

Here anti-communism ceases to be personal fear and becomes ideological labour.

Kazan helped legitimise the political conditions under which the Hollywood Left was being dismantled.

The celebrated individualism of his later films consequently becomes difficult to separate from the historical triumph of that same individualism over solidarity.

No film exposes this problem more violently than On the Waterfront.

The film is aesthetically magnificent precisely because it mobilises so much genuine class imagery. Dock labour. Hiring lines. Physical exhaustion. Corrupt hierarchy. Economic dependence. Masculine humiliation. Workers waiting to be selected for employment.

Its world is unmistakably proletarian. It takes 20 minutes into the film and several days of head scratching into the assignment before Greg Peck as a journalist thinks to ask a Jewish person what it ius like experiencing prejudice.

But politically the film performs an extraordinary inversion.

The organised working-class institution becomes the primary source of oppression.

The individual who informs upon it becomes the moral centre.

The collective is corrupt.

The solitary conscience is pure.

This is liberal anti-communism translated into melodrama.

The structural conflict between capital and labour recedes almost completely. The waterfront’s ruling antagonism becomes worker against union bureaucracy rather than worker against capital.

The union occupies the narrative position that capitalism itself might otherwise have occupied.

The effect is ideological displacement.

The institution through which labour might collectively exercise power is represented primarily as tyranny; salvation arrives through the morally courageous individual who cooperates with legal authority.

It is difficult to imagine a more perfect dramatic expression of Cold War liberalism.

Orson Welles understood the ideological structure immediately. Asked about Kazan, he described him as a man who had informed on colleagues and then made On the Waterfront, which Welles characterised as a celebration of the informer. Yet Welles added the indispensable qualification: Kazan was a very good director.

That final qualification matters.

A vulgar Marxism might dismiss Kazan as merely reactionary and therefore aesthetically worthless.

Serious Marxist criticism should do the opposite.

The ideological contradiction matters because the films are so accomplished.

Works of art do not simply reproduce the political consciousness of their makers. They contain fractures, residues and contradictions produced by history itself.

Kazan’s films frequently know more than Kazan’s politics.

They reveal the deformation of human beings by authority even when their narratives seek redemption through individualism.

They expose the violence of hierarchy even while refusing to imagine collective emancipation.

They repeatedly show people trapped inside structures while insisting that salvation must occur through personal courage.

This is precisely the contradiction of American liberalism.

Society causes the wound, lol.

The individual is instructed to heal himself.

The 1999 controversy surrounding Kazan’s honorary Academy Award therefore reproduced the contradiction in spectacular form. Some applauded; others remained seated. The institutional language of the ceremony insisted upon separating artistic achievement from political history, while the dissenters refused that separation.

The Academy wished to celebrate individual genius.

History returned the collective.

The absent workers of the blacklist entered the ceremony symbolically through those who refused to stand.

The dispute was not finally about whether Kazan could direct actors.

Nobody could doubt that.

It concerned who is permitted to become the hero of cultural history and whose sacrificed labour disappears beneath the monument.

There is therefore something almost dialectically perfect about Kazan’s position in American cinema.

He emerged from collectivist theatre.

He became the supreme director of individual psychological authenticity.

He made films about institutional oppression.

He collaborated with a repressive institution.

He portrayed working-class suffering with extraordinary sympathy.

He helped legitimise a political system that destroyed the livelihoods of left-wing cultural workers.

He distrusted mass political conformity.

He survived by complying with one of the most powerful conformist campaigns in American cultural history.

Kazan’s cinema should therefore be read neither as innocent art nor simply as propaganda.

It is the cinema of contradiction.

It demonstrates how bourgeois culture can absorb the imagery of rebellion while neutralising its collective political content.

Its workers suffer but rarely seize power.

Its rebels revolt but largely alone.

Its outsiders demand recognition rather than transformation.

Its institutions are cruel, but capitalism itself remains curiously difficult to name.

The social totality fragments into fathers, bosses, lovers, priests, demagogues and corrupt officials.

The structure becomes psychology.

Class becomes character.

Politics becomes conscience.

And conscience, finally, becomes the ideological sanctuary of the bourgeois individual.

That is why Kazan remains so important.

His films belong to a historical moment in which American capitalism learned how to represent dissent without surrendering ideological control over its meaning.

Kazan gave Hollywood rebellion with extraordinary emotional force.

But he gave it rebellion deprived of revolution. Are you telling me what? I can't believe I watched it again and felt the same.


Gentleman's Agreement (1947)

Directed by Elia Kazan

Genres - Drama, Romance  |   Release Date - Nov 11, 1947  |   Run Time - 118 min.  |