.png)
For 1945 this is powerful stuff, a seminal seminar in crossover and able to tell you more about history, narrative, meta-history, film-making, World War 2 and the USA than Citizen Kane might ever.
Mind you, this is virtually post-the-war and the thing hasn't gone off yet, it's one the last pictures from Innocentlandia.
With everything smashed into the firm format of the hour, film noir. Film noir comedy and the urban. The adventure of rooms and clubs and thugs and romance of an erotic kind never far from the lit cigarette. It's a film of ambiguous charm.
When the year 1945 dawned, the world was dragging itself across the finish line of a global conflict that had reshaped the century. Victory in Europe was only weeks away. In the United States, the shadows of war clung tightly to the culture—cinema included.
It was into this atmosphere, one still thick with uncertainty, that Two O’Clock Courage slipped, like a half-remembered dream or a face glimpsed in a mirror through steam. A minor RKO programmer with modest intentions, it nonetheless now serves as a curious transitional text: one foot firmly planted in the drawing-room whodunits of the 1930s, the other groping blindly through the noirish gloom into which postwar American cinema would soon sink.
.png)
.png)
.png)
Directed by Anthony Mann—before his name became etched into the darker chapters of genre history—Two O’Clock Courage is a crepuscular farce dressed in fog and false identities. Its skeletal structure borrows from its predecessor, Two in the Dark (1936), but Mann’s film is no mere replica.
It reconfigures its source into something faintly off-kilter, touched by both frivolity and menace. While its tonal lurches from slapstick to somberness may prevent it from achieving the distilled fatalism of canonical noir, it exists nonetheless as a twilight film, caught—quite literally—between comedy and crime, light and shadow, memory and oblivion.
.png)
.png)
.png)
The film begins with disorientation. A man, unnamed, emerges from the mist at the intersection of Ocean View Drive and Arch Street. His face bears a head wound; his mind is as empty as the nocturnal city streets. Played by Tom Conway, this dazed figure immediately evokes noir archetypes: the loner, the fugitive, the man whose past may be a weapon turned against him.
.png)
.png)
Conway, whose suave demeanor never quite shakes its gentlemanly heritage, moves through the scene with the hesitancy of someone unsure not only of his surroundings, but of himself.
What might have been a descent into dread is immediately undercut—intentionally—by the arrival of a female taxi driver, the plucky and impossibly upbeat Patty Mitchell. Ann Rutherford plays her like a wartime Rosie the Riveter with a knack for wisecracks and an indefatigable optimism that teeters on the unbearable.
.png)
.png)
Patty doesn’t just rescue the man from the street; she insinuates herself into his unraveling life, becomes Watson to his head-wounded Holmes, and refuses—point-blank—to believe that he is capable of the murder the newspapers are now laying at his feet.
Mann’s direction here is workmanlike, never transcendent, but attentive to tone. This was early in his career—before his extraordinary collaborations with cinematographer John Alton, before Raw Deal or T-Men.
.png)
.png) |
| Tom Conway and Ann Rutherford in cabbie noir Two O' Clock Courage (1945) |
.png) |
| The matchbook clue in Two O' Clock Courage (1945) |
The noir is faded in and out but certainly at the head of the action, in, indeed, with the opening shot without doubt being one of the most film noir things imaginable. Check it.
So yes to chiaroscuro stylings that would later define his reputation are mostly absent. And yet, in moments—the fog, a noirish close-up as memory returns, a brief shot where a gunshot splits silence—one glimpses the darker Mann stirring beneath the surface. There is a restraint in his approach to the farce, a discipline.
The film flirts with broad comedy but rarely submits to it fully. The humor, though abundant, is always undercut by the sobering reality that identity itself is a fragile and precarious construct.
The plot, written before the invention of the Post-It note, which pivots around the theft of a play entitled Two O’Clock Courage, is a twisty, tangled affair. Names are lies, motives shift, and the past is a jigsaw puzzle scattered across city blocks. This is a film built around contrivance, and it rarely attempts to conceal it.
Hotel rooms conveniently stack characters, radio reports arrive with divine punctuality, and clues fall like breadcrumbs beneath the characters’ feet. Yet these contrivances do not damage the work—they are part of its RKO DNA. Mann, rather than resisting them, builds a kind of momentum from their inevitability.
In this regard, Conway’s amnesiac functions less as a traditional noir protagonist than as a distillation of noir’s deeper metaphysical anxiety: the fear that one’s past, once uncovered, will not be a salvation but a curse. That he turns out to be innocent—morally intact, even charming—is perhaps the film’s greatest deviation from the genre’s moral architecture. In true noir, innocence is a lie we tell ourselves before the spiral begins. Here, it becomes a punchline.
.png)
.png)
Jane Greer appears briefly, but memorably, in what would be her cinematic debut—billed, ludicrously, as "Bettejane." Her presence is electric, sultry, and filled with the magnetic opacity that would come to define her in Out of the Past (1947).
Here, she plays a nightclub girl with shadows behind her eyes, a character type half-drawn from the noir playbook. She is not the femme fatale proper—though Jean Brooks, in a supporting role, nearly claims that mantle—but she suggests its possibility, gesturing toward a future in which women like her would no longer be ornamental, but fatal.
.png)
But rather than dramatizing this shift, the film turns it into a quirk—an eccentricity to be admired but not sustained. Rutherford is lively, intelligent, and central to the narrative, but her spunk is more endearing than empowering.
.png)
.png)
.png) |
| Ann Rutherford and Jane Greer in Two O' Clock Courage (1945) |
She helps the man, but never threatens to overshadow him. By the final reel, her tomboyish resilience has softened into romantic subordination. It is a feminism diluted by genre convention, sparkling on the surface but with no true ballast beneath.
Still, in the larger context of 1945, even this shallow feminism speaks volumes. America was beginning the slow, bruising process of reintegration: soldiers returning, women exiting the factories. The brief wartime expansion of female agency was about to be reeled in, repackaged, and sold as temporary.
.png)
.png)
That Two O’Clock Courage permits a woman to drive the plot—even in a comic register—is indicative of the cultural moment’s lingering tensions. Patty Mitchell, like so many wartime women, finds herself at the wheel. But the destination, we sense, has already been chosen for her.
The film’s noir credentials, though contested by its levity, are nonetheless intact. Its opening sequence alone—fog-shrouded streets, a wounded man stumbling from darkness—would not be out of place in a Fritz Lang thriller.
.png)
The amnesia plot, too, is a noir staple, deployed here not for existential horror but for gentle suspense. We see noir’s embryonic form: the distrust of identity, the pervasive suggestion of duplicity, the idea that one’s self is not fixed but fluid. Even the milieu—a world of shadowy hotels, duplicitous playwrights, and exploitative producers—echoes the noir landscape of corruption and compromised ambition.
.png)
.png)
.png)
What prevents Two O’Clock Courage from ascending to full-fledged noir, however, is its refusal to submit to despair. It flirts with darkness but retreats to charm. Its criminals are more theatrical than tragic, its hero more confused than doomed.
Where noir wallows in fatalism, Courage preserves the possibility of restoration. In this way, it belongs to a specific transitional moment: between the drawing-room puzzle and the psychological abyss, between the screwball and the suicidal.
It is also—fittingly—an American film about American identity, made during a year when that identity was fraying and reforming. The protagonist’s journey from amnesia to remembrance mirrors the nation’s own postwar reckoning.
.png)
.png) |
| Ann Rutherford, Jane Greer and Tom Conway in Two O' Clock Courage (1945) |
Who are we, after such violence? What do we do with the past? The film’s answer is characteristically optimistic: we marry the girl, clear our name, and step out of the fog into a brighter morning. But the fog, we sense, never really lifts. It clings to the edges of the frame, to the corners of the characters’ expressions. It reminds us that forgetting is never quite complete, and remembering never entirely safe.
.png)
.png) |
| Mists of time hypnotic flashback technique in Two O' Clock Courage (1945) |
This is not to suggest that Two O’Clock Courage is some buried masterpiece. It is not. It is too slight, too inconsistent, too eager to please. Its tonal imbalance—a comedic bounce followed by a noirish stumble—creates a rhythm that is intriguing but never wholly coherent.
Yet therein lies its fascination. As a piece of cinematic archaeology, it is invaluable: a celluloid hinge connecting one era to another. It is what happens when the Falcon grows weary, and the shadows begin to lengthen.
.png)
The performances vary in flavor. Conway’s dapper confusion is both credible and oddly soothing. He lacks the menace or mania that the role might have demanded, but his detachment serves the narrative’s mood of dreamy uncertainty.
Rutherford, meanwhile, overflows with vim. Her performance is pitched to a frequency one either tunes into or tunes out entirely. She is less a person than an energy, a persistent nudge away from melancholy. Together, they are an odd couple, lacking romantic heat but generating a kind of platonic momentum.
.png)
.png)
The supporting cast—particularly Richard Lane as a manic reporter and Emory Parnell as a dangerously oblivious policeman—play their parts with a kind of vaudevillian exuberance. Theirs is the world of stock characters and recycled lines, but they inhabit it with gusto.
.png)
.png)
.png)
Jean Brooks, in one of her last screen appearances, lends the film a weary elegance; her screen time may be limited, but her presence lingers.
Historically, rhetorically, Two O’Clock Courage is an emblem of B-picture efficiency: shot quickly, structured tightly, and designed to fill a slot on a double bill. RKO specialized in such fare, churning out modest thrillers and noir precursors with a grim efficiency.
.png)
And yet, within this industrial framework, flashes of artistry and experimentation often emerged. Mann would soon ascend to more ambitious projects, but the lessons learned here—the rhythm of revelation, the tension between clarity and confusion—would inform his later, darker, more brutal work.
It all means, it all points to, in the midst of film history, even in the smaller entries to the canon, in the very aisles, it all means, and can be shown, that Two O’Clock Courage is a film about uncertainty—in identity, in narrative, in tone.
.png)
.png) |
| Journalism and media film noir framing in Two O' Clock Courage (1945) |
It never quite knows what it wants to be. That, paradoxically, is its strength. It is neither fully noir nor entirely comedy; it is both imitation and innovation. It contains within its slender frame the vestiges of an older cinematic order and the embryonic traces of a new one. It reminds us that genre is not a fixed taxonomy but a trembling spectrum.
And so, the man regains his name. The crime is solved. The couple, improbably, kiss. The fog, as always, remains.
.png)
Two O'Clock Courage (1945)
Directed by Anthony Mann
Genres - Comedy, Crime, Drama, Mystery-Suspense | Sub-Genres - Cabbie Noir | Release Date - Apr 13, 1945 | Run Time - 68 min. | Wikipedia Two O' Clock Courage
.png)
